Easter Orders

Dinner Rolls ($15/dz): Soft and fluffy, our made-from-scratch dinner rolls have become a holiday tradition for many of our customers!

Herb Butter ($6.50/8oz): A savory blend of classic herbs in creamy, whipped butter brings a little something extra to the table. It adds a perfect savory spin to our dinner rolls but is also great on potatoes, vegetables, and grilled cheese sandwiches!

Honey Butter ($6.50/8oz): Creamy and sweet, this butter is a delicious treat and pairs perfectly with our dinner rolls, as well as cornbread, pancakes, french toast and so much more!

Quiche ($25 ea): If you are serving brunch, quiche is a must-have! Our quiche is crustless which means there is more room for amazing flavor from delicious fillings. (Crustless quiche is also gluten free!) Choose broccoli & cheese or ham & bacon.  Each quiche serves 8-10.

Key Lime Pie ($30 ea): An Elm Tree Cottage specialty with a loyal following!  Creamy sweet and tart perfection baked in a homemade graham cracker crust with fresh whipped cream.

Carrot Cake ($45/$60): Two layers of delicious and perfectly spiced carrot cake topped with a sweet and tangy cream creese frosting. Small cake serves 8-10; Large cake serves 12-15.

Mini Cupcakes ($20/dz): One dozen mini cupcakes provide a perfect bite for kids and adults alike.  Each box include four flavors: vanilla, chocolate, lemon and carrot.

Mini Assortment ($45): Minis are a perfect bite of sweet delicousness and since they are small, it’s ok to have more than one! Or even two! This box of three dozen pieces includes mini cookies (chocolate chip, M&M, and oatmeal salted caramel) and mini bars (s’mores bars, raspberry bars and throwback brownies).

Frosted Sugar Cookies ($45/dz): Soft vanilla almond sugar cookies in an assortment of spring and Easter shapes, topped with our delicious almond cream cheese frosting and festive seasonal designs.

Cadbury Chip Cookies ($42/$28): Don’t miss out on this annual treat! We are baking Cadbury Chip cookies our classic jumbo size, and also a bit smaller party size.  Order them to share, or save for yourself.  They won’t be around forever and freeze beautifully!