Easter Orders
Pre-order our most popular Easter items! Pick up is Saturday, April 4: 10am – 12pm OR 12-2pm.
Dinner Rolls: (Fresh baked/$16 dz; Frozen Bake-at-Home/$14 dz) Soft and fluffy, our made-from-scratch dinner rolls have become a holiday tradition for many of our customers! Choose fresh baked, or frozen roll dough to bake at home.
Herb Butter ($6.50/8oz): A savory blend of classic herbs in creamy, whipped butter brings a little something extra to the table. It adds a perfect savory spin to our dinner rolls but is also great on potatoes, vegetables, and grilled cheese sandwiches!
Honey Butter ($6.50/8oz): Creamy and sweet, this butter is a delicious treat and pairs perfectly with our dinner rolls, as well as cornbread, pancakes, french toast and so much more!
Cinnamon Rolls (4/$20 or 6/$30): Soft and fluffy cinnamon rolls with cream cheese frosting. IYKYK.
Key Lime Pie ($30): An Elm Tree Cottage specialty with a loyal following! Creamy sweet and tart perfection baked in a homemade graham cracker crust with fresh whipped cream.
Carrot Cake ($45): Two layers of delicious and perfectly spiced carrot cake topped with a sweet and tangy cream creese frosting. Serves 8-10.
Lemon Bars ($16): Our lemon bars are so popular we’re making them available for pre-order in a box of 4 bars! With a shortbread crust and tangy lemon filling, they are the best version of a classic lemon bar.
Mini Dessert Box ($40): There is something for everyone in our mini dessert box! This 32-piece box includes mini chocolate & vanilla cupcakes with Easter flair, mini chocolate chip, spring M&M and sugar cookies, and mini smore’s bars, raspberry bars and caramel brownies.
Cadbury Mini Egg Cookies ($28/$42): Don’t miss this annual treat! We fill our cookie dough with Cadbury Mini Eggs and bake our classic jumbo size, and also a bit smaller party size. Order them to share, or save for yourself. They won’t be around forever and freeze beautifully!
Sugar Cookie Kits ($20/$38): Easter egg and bunny sugar cookies are ready to decorate with four colors of buttercream and three sprinkles & candies. Perfect for entertaining kids of all ages! Choose a kit of 6 ($20) or 12 ($38) cookies.
Complete the following form to place your Easter Order: